Sunday, December 23, 2012

Taxes and Social Mobility


My cousin wrote an expose of the lucky sperm club, linked below, that makes references to Libertarian reluctance to pay taxes. As a libertarian I understand that taxes must be collected to defend the country and maintain a judiciary to interpret the law and a police to keep it. I would disagree with any tax being an unfair burden, though too high a tax is a form of enslavement where property is unfairly taken from an individual for redistribution to another. Taxes that are so costly to administer that they generate more heat through friction then revenue are especially noxious since the usual beneficiaries are financiers, tax lawyers, accountants and lobbyist. Steve Schwarzman of Blackstone defense of the carry interest comes to mind along with all the other tax benefits his firm enjoys. I prefer simple to interpret taxes that avoids re-distributing to fat cats.

Taxes that are complicated and costly to administer, and labeled as “fair”, have more to do with life as a lottery with preordained results described in The Grasshopper and The Ant. Unlike Adam Smith's invisible hand of players acting in their self interest directing economic activity with a price mechanism toward a common good, other systems require costly influence peddlers to define what is fair and administrators to maintain it. It is my contention that those working outside of the invisible hand to direct and administer are the self perpetuating class that propagates complex and expensive taxes that hinder social mobility most unfairly. 

No comments:

Post a Comment